Skip to main content

Software team guide · Code reviewers & maintainers

Best practices for code reviewers using multiple AI models

Use another model to inspect a change without handing over your merge decision. Compare independent findings, challenge weak objections and write review comments that explain a real problem.

By MultipleChat · Updated

Start here

A review finding needs a trigger and a consequence.

Give the models the diff, relevant surrounding code and intended behavior. Ask them to show why a concern applies to this change. A plausible warning without a reachable condition belongs in the questions list, not automatically in the blocking findings.

Side-by-side AI

Compare independent reviews of the same diff.

AI Collaboration

Draft, critique and refine a review report.

AI Conversation

Challenge a disputed finding before posting it.

Review with context

1. Supply the contract around the diff.

Include the change’s purpose, the relevant call sites and test results you actually have. Ask for missing context explicitly. A snippet may look unsafe even though a caller enforces the necessary condition—or look safe while a caller violates it.

Google’s review guidance covers design, functionality, complexity and tests. Use a focused rubric to keep the review useful rather than treating every stylistic preference as a defect.

Try this prompt

Review this diff with its surrounding code: [paste]. Intended behavior: [paste]. Identify defects introduced by the change. For each finding, give the affected location, reachable trigger, user impact and supporting code. Separate questions and style preferences.

Google: what to look for in a code review ↗

Refine the findings

2. Use AI Collaboration to remove unsupported objections.

Let one model draft a review and another critique its reasoning before the final revision. Ask the reviewer to look for existing safeguards, incompatible assumptions and duplicate findings.

Check every retained finding yourself against the actual code. Agreement between the drafting and reviewing models is not confirmation of a bug.

Try this prompt

Review this proposed review report against the supplied diff and context. For each objection, look for code that supports or contradicts it. Remove duplicates, downgrade unsupported claims to questions and produce a concise report with evidence.

Challenge a finding

3. Use AI Conversation for a specific disagreement.

When the author and review disagree, provide both explanations and the contract. Ask the selected models to challenge the reasoning and propose a reproducer.

For example, a suspected race condition needs a possible interleaving and an affected invariant. If the given locking behavior rules that out, update the finding instead of escalating its wording.

Try this prompt

Proposed finding: [paste]. Author response: [paste]. Relevant contract and code: [paste]. Challenge both arguments. What concrete execution or test would settle this? Preserve uncertainty where required context is missing.

Write actionable feedback

4. Tell the author what fails and why it matters.

Draft feedback around the observed or demonstrable issue. Explain the requirement and a way to verify the fix. Keep the final approval decision in your normal review process.

  • Distinguish blocking defects, clarifying questions and optional suggestions.
  • Reference the relevant code location and triggering conditions.
  • Request an appropriate regression test and recheck the changed code.

Common questions

A few details before you start.

Does this automatically review my pull requests?

This guide uses code and context you provide in MultipleChat. It does not describe an automatic pull-request integration or posting review comments to a repository.

Should I paste the full repository into the prompt?

Start with the diff and the context needed to understand it. If the model needs a caller, schema or contract, provide that material rather than asking it to guess.

Can a second model approve the merge?

Models can review reasoning and suggest checks. The accountable reviewer still inspects the change and applies the team’s merge criteria.

How do I choose a MultipleChat workflow?

Use side-by-side AI for independent answers, cooperative AI Collaboration for draft–review–revision, and AI Conversation for visible pushback on a draft. Paste short text or code into Compare Mode; use an appropriate chat or Collaboration workflow for file uploads.

Sources & related guides

Check the details that matter to you.

Written by MultipleChat. The role-specific prompts and workflows are editorial recommendations, not recorded model results. Product behavior checked against this application on 16 November 2026. Engineering references provide background; they do not endorse MultipleChat.

Your next step

Make the second review useful to the author.

Compare independent answers side by side, automate draft–review–revision with AI Collaboration, or challenge a draft with AI Conversation. Signed-in Compare Mode includes Free access with limits; Collaboration requires paid access and available AI allowance.